Views: 1
BYD, Geely, and CATL are competing to shave seconds off electric car charging times. But is that what drivers actually need? Every few months, a Chinese manufacturer announces a new ultra-fast charging record.
BYD unveiled the second generation of its "Flash Charging" technology: going from 10% to 70% in 5 minutes, and from 10% to 97% in about 9 minutes. Shortly after, Geely responded with 4 minutes and 30 seconds for the first interval and 8 minutes and 40 seconds for the second. Meanwhile, CATL claims it can reach 80% charge in under 4 minutes.
First, it is important to note that these figures come from laboratory settings, not real-world driving. Furthermore, when the difference between competitors is a mere 30 seconds, the question inevitably arises: does this race make sense?
Geely boasts of a charging station capable of peak power outputs of 2,250 kilowatts. That is an impressive figure, but it requires careful interpretation. In certified tests, the Lynk&Co 10 electric car reached an actual peak of 1,093 kilowatts. In other words, the vehicle does not draw the full power the charger is capable of delivering.
Moreover, these brands achieve these results under ideal conditions: optimal temperatures, pre-conditioned batteries, and proprietary chargers. That is hardly the experience of an average driver at an electric charging station on a rainy Tuesday.
Most telling of all, a Geely executive admitted that charging speeds are approaching physical limits and that future improvements will yield diminishing returns. Going from 20 minutes to 5 minutes transforms the driver's experience, but going from 5 minutes to 4 and a half minutes changes nothing.
Charging anxiety isn't resolved by shaving off seconds, but rather by three far more mundane factors:
. Price: making charging affordable
. Reliability: ensuring the charger always works
. Availability: having enough charging points to avoid queues
The real bottleneck lies in the availability of charging points. BYD has already opened 10,000 of the 20,000 stations it aims to have by 2026, and Geely plans to exceed 100,000 charging points by late 2027. However, each brand is building its own network using its own technology. It is as if every oil company required a different type of fuel tank.
This is where collaboration would make the most sense: a common, cost-effective, and reliable standard that any car can use. Interestingly, Geely itself acknowledges that the future will resemble traditional gas stations, with infrastructure shared across brands.
Technological competition is healthy and has driven charging capabilities to levels that were unthinkable just a few years ago. Yet, once the five-minute mark is reached, shaving off further seconds is primarily a matter of marketing. Drivers don't need a record-breaking speed; they need to reach a working charger, pay a fair price, and get on with their journey.